August 7th & September 18th
Whitchurch Prog festival, UK
De Pul, Uden, The Netherlands
By Mark Nickol and Ed Sander
The photos on this
page are taken at the Robin 2 in Bilston on December 12th 1998. This was former singer Glyn
Protheroe's farewell gig. The pictures I took during that gig were too good never to publish,
so therefore I have pasted them into these reviews. The show's still the same, it's just a
Whitchurch Prog Festival
By Mark Nickol
The Whitchurch festival is a 3-days event in the small town of Whitchurch in
of England. The Friday and Saturday gigs normally involve prog bands, while the
Sunday is filled with blues music. This year's Friday headliners were 'Regenesis'.
This was my first chance to hear the new lead singer, who sounds,
probably even more like Peter Gabriel than Glynn Protheroe (their last
lead singer), although he is not as smiley as Glynn. A very impressive
performance, though, and he coped with the theatrics well as well. On
the Sunday, I was discussing with a friend, however, that maybe they
should be varying their set a bit more. I have seen them probably more
than 10 times now, and every time they have started with Watcher..
and finished with The Knife. Can we have a bit more variety, please ?
Having said that, it was great to hear The Battle of Epping Forest.
ReGenesis at "De Pul"
By Ed Sander
It was only one and a half month after seeing the band perform in Whitchurch
when I saw them again in my hometown (Uden). The setlist was almost the same as in
Whitchurch, although In The Cage had been replaced by The Lamia
and seemingly Return of the Giant Hogweed had been swapped with Firth of
Fifth at the last moment (it was still present in that day's written setlist).
After a rather long intro tape, Watchers ... opened the show, with
bat-wings and all. Immediately it became clear that this was one of those deafening Pul
nights. That venue's sound engineer must have
a real problem with his ears, or wanted to give the rest of the audience one.
Although not as painfully loud as some other recent gigs, the volume was once again above
As mentioned, Hogweed was deleted from the set, something which made me
quite happy because personally I think the track is a load of bullocks (heresy #1 !).
The replacement, Firth of Fifth was not played without the occassional bum
note from the keyboard player (wearing an Eric 'I'm not fat, I'm bog boned'
Cartman South Park shirt) but was nevertheless a lot more enjoyable than the botanical tune.
When the new vocalist, who indeed sounds more like Gabriel than Gabriel
himself, introduced the next song with a story about old Henry, he mentioned that Henry
must have been at least as old as the 147-years-old guitarist had his
birthday that day. As you can imagine, The Musical Box followed. A fine version
with perfect theatrics and old man's mask in the closing section.
As in Whitchurch, the band proceeded with the full version of The Battle of
Epping Forest. A nice tune but in my opinion it drags a bit too long and should
have been half its length (heresy #2 !). Nice to see once, but there's better Genesis
tunes to choose from.
I was slightly disappointed by the fact that The Lamia (not one of my
favourite Lamb songs) had replaced In the Cage, although it was indeed fascinating
to see this song live on stage.
Supper's Ready will always be the highlight of the set for me. It must
be one of my favourite songs ever and the performance was brilliant again ! Any ReGenesis
gig is well worth the money if they play this, if only for the Flower costume. I had
just spend 5 days in Norway and singing 'Now I'm back again, and babe it's going to work out fine', to my wife
gave me chills all over my back.
Set closer was Cinema Show followed by the drum solo and Los
Endos which included an interesting inclusion of some lyrics from Supper's
The band returned for Fountain .., a track which has never been able to
get me extremely excited (heresy #3 !) and The Knife. I've now seen ReGenesis
three times, including last years performance in Southampton and
like Mark I would have preferred a more surprising encore for a change.
Anyway, another splendid night with a great band. The only thing which I would
like to see ReGenesis do for a change is improvise a bit with some of the songs instead
of playing all the songs note-for-note as the originals. On the other hand, most
people would probably prefer to see them play the originals as they are .....
Watcher of the Skies
The Fountain of Salmacis
Return of the Giant Hogweed (Whitchurch)
The Musical Box
The Battle Of Epping Forest
In the Cage (Whitchurch)
The Lamia (Uden)
Cinema Show/Los Endos
(All photos © Bart Jan van der Vorst)